fix(workdir): preserve mutation and command safety through diagnostics

crates/workdir/src/http.rs

@@ -716,10 +716,23 @@ mod client {
                     "mismatched response after checkout mutation".into(),
                 )),
                 Ok(_) => Err(Self::mismatch("checkout_execute")),
-                Err(WorkdirError::Unavailable(_) | WorkdirError::Transport(_)) if mutation => {
+                Err(error)
-                    Err(WorkdirError::OutcomeUnknown(
+                    if mutation
+                        && matches!(
+                            error.classification_source(),
+                            WorkdirError::Unavailable(_) | WorkdirError::Transport(_)
+                        ) =>
+                {
+                    let outcome = WorkdirError::OutcomeUnknown(
                         "checkout transport failed; effects may have occurred".into(),
-                    ))
+                    );
+                    Err(match error.denial_reason() {
+                        Some(reason) => WorkdirError::DenialContext {
+                            reason,
+                            source: Box::new(outcome),
+                        },
+                        None => outcome,
+                    })
                 }
                 Err(error) => Err(error),
             }

crates/workdir/src/router.rs

@@ -166,7 +166,12 @@ impl RoutedSessionState {
         for handle in handles {
             match self.session.command_status(handle.clone()).await {
                 Ok(status) => self.mark_terminal(&handle, status),
-                Err(WorkdirError::UnknownCommand(_)) => {
+                Err(error)
+                    if matches!(
+                        error.classification_source(),
+                        WorkdirError::UnknownCommand(_)
+                    ) =>
+                {
                     self.active_commands
                         .lock()
                         .unwrap_or_else(std::sync::PoisonError::into_inner)

crates/workdir/src/scope.rs

@@ -240,8 +240,18 @@ impl WorkdirScopeLease {
                         .expect("scoped command set mutex poisoned")
                         .remove(&command_id);
                 }
-                (Ok(()), Err(WorkdirError::UnknownCommand(_)))
+                (cancel, Err(error))
-                | (Err(WorkdirError::UnknownCommand(_)), Err(WorkdirError::UnknownCommand(_))) => {
+                    if matches!(
+                        error.classification_source(),
+                        WorkdirError::UnknownCommand(_)
+                    ) && match &cancel {
+                        Ok(()) => true,
+                        Err(error) => matches!(
+                            error.classification_source(),
+                            WorkdirError::UnknownCommand(_)
+                        ),
+                    } =>
+                {
                     self.broker.authority.publish_terminal_if_missing(
                         &command_id,
                         CommandStatus::Cancelled,

crates/workdir/tests/command_denial_diagnostics.rs

@@ -0,0 +1,185 @@
+//! Wire diagnostics must not change command disappearance or lease release.
+//! Fake command handles only; no OS process is started, polled, or cancelled.
+use async_trait::async_trait;
+use std::{path::Path, sync::Arc};
+use tempfile::TempDir;
+use workdir::*;
+
+#[derive(Debug)]
+struct CommandFailureSession {
+    local: LocalWorkdirSession,
+    code: &'static str,
+    depth: u8,
+    cancel_ok: bool,
+}
+impl CommandFailureSession {
+    fn new(root: &Path, code: &'static str, depth: u8, cancel_ok: bool) -> Arc<Self> {
+        Arc::new(Self {
+            local: LocalWorkdirSession::new(
+                manifest::Scope::writable(root).unwrap(),
+                root.to_path_buf(),
+            ),
+            code,
+            depth,
+            cancel_ok,
+        })
+    }
+    fn failure(&self) -> WorkdirError {
+        let mut error = serde_json::from_value::<http::WorkdirTransportError>(serde_json::json!({
+            "code": self.code, "message": "safe fixture error",
+            "denial_reason": (self.depth > 0).then_some(WorkdirDenialReason::ReadOnlySession),
+        }))
+        .unwrap()
+        .into_workdir_error();
+        if self.depth == 2 {
+            error = WorkdirError::DenialContext {
+                reason: WorkdirDenialReason::OsPermissionDenied,
+                source: Box::new(error),
+            };
+        }
+        error
+    }
+}
+#[async_trait]
+impl WorkdirSession for CommandFailureSession {
+    fn workdir(&self) -> &Workdir {
+        self.local.workdir()
+    }
+    fn capabilities(&self) -> WorkdirSessionCapabilities {
+        self.local.capabilities()
+    }
+    async fn authorize_scope_path(
+        &self,
+        r: WorkdirScopeAuthorizationRequest,
+    ) -> Result<(), WorkdirError> {
+        self.local.authorize_scope_path(r).await
+    }
+    async fn scope_rules_overlap(
+        &self,
+        r: WorkdirScopeOverlapRequest,
+    ) -> Result<bool, WorkdirError> {
+        self.local.scope_rules_overlap(r).await
+    }
+    async fn stat(&self, r: StatRequest) -> Result<StatResult, WorkdirError> {
+        self.local.stat(r).await
+    }
+    async fn read(&self, r: ReadRequest) -> Result<ReadResult, WorkdirError> {
+        self.local.read(r).await
+    }
+    async fn write(&self, r: WriteRequest) -> Result<WriteResult, WorkdirError> {
+        self.local.write(r).await
+    }
+    async fn edit(&self, r: EditRequest) -> Result<EditResult, WorkdirError> {
+        self.local.edit(r).await
+    }
+    async fn list(&self, r: ListRequest) -> Result<ListResult, WorkdirError> {
+        self.local.list(r).await
+    }
+    async fn glob(&self, r: GlobRequest) -> Result<GlobResult, WorkdirError> {
+        self.local.glob(r).await
+    }
+    async fn grep(&self, r: GrepRequest) -> Result<GrepResult, WorkdirError> {
+        self.local.grep(r).await
+    }
+    async fn start_command(&self, _: CommandRequest) -> Result<CommandHandle, WorkdirError> {
+        Ok(CommandHandle("fake-command".into()))
+    }
+    async fn command_status(&self, _: CommandHandle) -> Result<CommandStatus, WorkdirError> {
+        Err(self.failure())
+    }
+    async fn command_output(&self, _: CommandOutputRequest) -> Result<CommandOutput, WorkdirError> {
+        Err(self.failure())
+    }
+    async fn cancel_command(&self, _: CommandHandle) -> Result<(), WorkdirError> {
+        if self.cancel_ok {
+            Ok(())
+        } else {
+            Err(self.failure())
+        }
+    }
+    async fn close(&self) -> Result<(), WorkdirError> {
+        self.local.close().await
+    }
+}
+fn command() -> CommandRequest {
+    CommandRequest {
+        command: "fake command, never executed".into(),
+        timeout_secs: 1,
+        output_limit: 100,
+        cwd: WorkdirPath::root(),
+        spill_dir: None,
+        tool_call_id: None,
+    }
+}
+fn scope() -> WorkdirToolScope {
+    WorkdirToolScope {
+        rules: vec![WorkdirToolScopeRule {
+            target: WorkdirPath::root(),
+            permission: WorkdirToolScopePermission::Write,
+            recursive: true,
+            symlink_policy: Default::default(),
+        }],
+        command: true,
+        cwd: WorkdirPath::root(),
+    }
+}
+
+#[tokio::test]
+async fn command_diagnostics_preserve_detach_disappearance_and_busy_guard() {
+    for code in ["unknown_command", "unavailable"] {
+        for depth in [0, 1, 2] {
+            let dir = TempDir::new().unwrap();
+            let router = WorkdirSessionRouter::new();
+            let alias = WorkdirAttachmentAlias::new("fixture").unwrap();
+            router
+                .attach(
+                    alias.clone(),
+                    CommandFailureSession::new(dir.path(), code, depth, false),
+                )
+                .unwrap();
+            let session = router.resolve(Some("fixture")).unwrap().session;
+            session.start_command(command()).await.unwrap();
+            let result = router.detach(&alias).await;
+            if code == "unknown_command" {
+                result.unwrap_or_else(|error| panic!("depth {depth}: {error:?}"));
+                assert!(router.resolve(Some("fixture")).is_err());
+            } else {
+                assert!(matches!(result, Err(WorkdirError::Conflict(_))));
+                assert!(router.resolve(Some("fixture")).is_ok());
+            }
+        }
+    }
+}
+
+#[tokio::test]
+async fn command_diagnostics_preserve_scope_close_and_write_lease_guard() {
+    for code in ["unknown_command", "unavailable"] {
+        for depth in [0, 1, 2] {
+            for cancel_ok in [false, true] {
+                let dir = TempDir::new().unwrap();
+                let broker = WorkdirToolBroker::new(CommandFailureSession::new(
+                    dir.path(),
+                    code,
+                    depth,
+                    cancel_ok,
+                ));
+                let child = broker.scope(scope()).await.unwrap();
+                child.start_command(command()).await.unwrap();
+                let result = child.close().await;
+                if code == "unknown_command" {
+                    result.unwrap_or_else(|error| {
+                        panic!("depth {depth}, cancel_ok={cancel_ok}: {error:?}")
+                    });
+                    assert!(!child.is_active());
+                    broker.scope(scope()).await.unwrap().close().await.unwrap();
+                } else {
+                    assert!(result.is_err());
+                    // Closing revokes new work immediately, but failed cleanup
+                    // must retain the write lease until ownership is resolved.
+                    assert!(!child.is_active());
+                    assert!(broker.scope(scope()).await.is_err());
+                }
+            }
+        }
+    }
+}

crates/workdir/tests/remote_denial_reasons.rs

@@ -4,7 +4,7 @@ use std::{
     io::{Read, Write},
     net::{TcpListener, TcpStream},
     thread,
-    time::Duration,
+    time::{Duration, Instant},
 };
 use workdir::{
     StatRequest, Workdir, WorkdirDenialReason as Reason, WorkdirPath, WorkdirSession,
@@ -15,7 +15,18 @@ use workdir::{
 };
 
 fn reply(listener: &TcpListener, status: &str, body: &str) {
-    let (mut stream, _) = listener.accept().unwrap();
+    listener.set_nonblocking(true).unwrap();
+    let deadline = Instant::now() + Duration::from_secs(5);
+    let (mut stream, _) = loop {
+        match listener.accept() {
+            Ok(connection) => break connection,
+            Err(error) if error.kind() == std::io::ErrorKind::WouldBlock => {
+                assert!(Instant::now() < deadline, "fake provider accept timed out");
+                thread::yield_now();
+            }
+            Err(error) => panic!("fake provider accept failed: {error}"),
+        }
+    };
     stream
         .set_read_timeout(Some(Duration::from_secs(5)))
         .unwrap();
@@ -108,3 +119,100 @@ async fn remote_http_denials_forward_only_typed_reasons_and_old_missing_reason()
         server.join().unwrap();
     }
 }
+
+#[tokio::test]
+async fn remote_checkout_diagnostics_preserve_mutation_outcome_and_read_failures() {
+    use workdir::{CheckoutOperation as Op, CheckoutRequest, WorkdirSessionCapability};
+    for code in [
+        Code::Unavailable,
+        Code::Transport,
+        Code::Denied,
+        Code::Conflict,
+        Code::OutcomeUnknown,
+    ] {
+        for reason in [None, Some(Reason::ReadOnlySession)] {
+            for operation in [
+                Op::Read {
+                    offset: 0,
+                    limit: 1,
+                    max_bytes: 10,
+                },
+                Op::Create {
+                    path: WorkdirPath::new("new.txt").unwrap(),
+                    content: b"fixture".to_vec(),
+                },
+                Op::Write {
+                    content: b"fixture".to_vec(),
+                    expected_hash: [0; 32],
+                },
+                Op::Edit {
+                    old_string: "old".into(),
+                    new_string: "new".into(),
+                    replace_all: false,
+                    expected_hash: [0; 32],
+                },
+            ] {
+                let mutation = operation.capability() != WorkdirSessionCapability::Read;
+                let expected_code =
+                    if mutation && matches!(code, Code::Unavailable | Code::Transport) {
+                        Code::OutcomeUnknown
+                    } else {
+                        code
+                    };
+                let listener = TcpListener::bind("127.0.0.1:0").unwrap();
+                let address = listener.local_addr().unwrap();
+                let error = serde_json::json!({"code":code, "message":"/secret/host provider-secret", "denial_reason":reason});
+                let server = thread::spawn(move || {
+                    reply(
+                        &listener,
+                        "200 OK",
+                        r#"{"session_id":"s","workdir_id":"w","capabilities":{"bits":63}}"#,
+                    );
+                    reply(
+                        &listener,
+                        &format!("{} Fixture failure", code.http_status()),
+                        &error.to_string(),
+                    );
+                });
+                let remote = RemoteWorkdirSession::open(
+                    reqwest::Client::builder()
+                        .no_proxy()
+                        .timeout(Duration::from_secs(5))
+                        .build()
+                        .unwrap(),
+                    format!("http://{address}").parse().unwrap(),
+                    "request-secret",
+                    Workdir::new("w").id().clone(),
+                    OpenWorkdirSessionRequest::default(),
+                )
+                .await
+                .unwrap();
+                let error = remote
+                    .checkout_execute(CheckoutRequest {
+                        target: WorkdirPath::root(),
+                        validator: vec![1],
+                        operation,
+                    })
+                    .await
+                    .unwrap_err();
+                server.join().unwrap();
+                let forwarded = WorkdirTransportError::from_workdir_error(&error);
+                assert_eq!(
+                    forwarded.code, expected_code,
+                    "{code:?}, {reason:?}, mutation={mutation}: {error:?}"
+                );
+                assert_eq!(error.denial_reason(), reason);
+                assert_eq!(forwarded.denial_reason, reason);
+                assert_eq!(forwarded.code.http_status(), expected_code.http_status());
+                if expected_code == Code::OutcomeUnknown {
+                    assert!(forwarded.message.contains("inspect before retrying"));
+                }
+                assert!(
+                    !serde_json::to_string(&forwarded)
+                        .unwrap()
+                        .contains("secret")
+                );
+            }
+        }
+    }
+}

crates/workspace-server/src/server.rs

@@ -1225,12 +1225,23 @@ impl workdir::WorkdirSession for ExternalProviderWorkdirSession {
                 "mismatched checkout mutation response".into(),
             )),
             Ok(_) => Err(Self::mismatch("checkout_execute")),
-            Err(workdir::WorkdirError::Unavailable(_) | workdir::WorkdirError::Transport(_))
+            Err(error)
-                if mutation =>
+                if mutation
+                    && matches!(
+                        error.classification_source(),
+                        workdir::WorkdirError::Unavailable(_) | workdir::WorkdirError::Transport(_)
+                    ) =>
             {
-                Err(workdir::WorkdirError::OutcomeUnknown(
+                let outcome = workdir::WorkdirError::OutcomeUnknown(
                     "checkout provider response lost; inspect effects before retry".into(),
-                ))
+                );
+                Err(match error.denial_reason() {
+                    Some(reason) => workdir::WorkdirError::DenialContext {
+                        reason,
+                        source: Box::new(outcome),
+                    },
+                    None => outcome,
+                })
             }
             Err(error) => Err(error),
         }
@@ -33033,6 +33044,7 @@ mod tests {
     mod drive_api_tests;
     mod drive_tests;
     mod drive_web_roundtrip_tests;
+    mod external_checkout_tests;
     mod subject_spawn_tests;
     mod subjektiv_jobs_tests;
     mod ticket_evidence_tests;

crates/workspace-server/src/server/tests/external_checkout_tests.rs

@@ -0,0 +1,129 @@
+//! External codec -> actual session dispatch -> mutation safety -> HTTP error.
+//! Channel fixture only; no product process or real mutation.
+use super::*;
+use workdir::{
+    CheckoutOperation as Op, CheckoutRequest, WorkdirDenialReason as Reason, WorkdirPath,
+    WorkdirSession, WorkdirSessionCapability, external::ExternalWorkdirOperationOutcome,
+    http::WorkdirTransportErrorCode as Code,
+};
+
+#[tokio::test]
+async fn external_checkout_diagnostics_preserve_mutation_outcome_and_read_failures() {
+    for code in [
+        Code::Unavailable,
+        Code::Transport,
+        Code::Denied,
+        Code::Conflict,
+        Code::OutcomeUnknown,
+    ] {
+        for reason in [None, Some(Reason::ReadOnlySession)] {
+            for operation in [
+                Op::Read {
+                    offset: 0,
+                    limit: 1,
+                    max_bytes: 10,
+                },
+                Op::Create {
+                    path: WorkdirPath::new("new.txt").unwrap(),
+                    content: b"fixture".to_vec(),
+                },
+                Op::Write {
+                    content: b"fixture".to_vec(),
+                    expected_hash: [0; 32],
+                },
+                Op::Edit {
+                    old_string: "old".into(),
+                    new_string: "new".into(),
+                    replace_all: false,
+                    expected_hash: [0; 32],
+                },
+            ] {
+                let mutation = operation.capability() != WorkdirSessionCapability::Read;
+                let expected_code =
+                    if mutation && matches!(code, Code::Unavailable | Code::Transport) {
+                        Code::OutcomeUnknown
+                    } else {
+                        code
+                    };
+                let (sender, mut commands) = tokio::sync::mpsc::channel(1);
+                let connection = Arc::new(ExternalProviderConnection {
+                    grant_id: "fixture-grant".into(),
+                    workdir_id: "fixture-workdir".into(),
+                    provider_instance_id: "fixture-provider".into(),
+                    generation: 1,
+                    expires_at: None,
+                    capabilities: workdir::WorkdirSessionCapabilities::ALL,
+                    admission: Arc::new(tokio::sync::Semaphore::new(16)),
+                    shutdown_confirmed: Arc::new(std::sync::atomic::AtomicBool::new(false)),
+                    sender,
+                });
+                let session = Arc::new(ExternalProviderWorkdirSession::new(connection, None));
+                let caller = tokio::spawn(async move {
+                    session
+                        .checkout_execute(CheckoutRequest {
+                            target: WorkdirPath::root(),
+                            validator: vec![1],
+                            operation,
+                        })
+                        .await
+                });
+                let command =
+                    tokio::time::timeout(std::time::Duration::from_secs(5), commands.recv())
+                        .await
+                        .unwrap()
+                        .unwrap();
+                let ExternalProviderCommand::Operation {
+                    operation,
+                    response,
+                    ..
+                } = command
+                else {
+                    panic!("expected dispatched operation");
+                };
+                assert!(matches!(
+                    operation,
+                    WorkdirSessionOperation::CheckoutExecute(_)
+                ));
+                let failed = serde_json::from_value::<ExternalWorkdirOperationOutcome>(json!({
+                    "outcome":"failed", "error":{"code":code, "denial_reason":reason},
+                }))
+                .unwrap();
+                let ExternalWorkdirOperationOutcome::Failed { error } = failed else {
+                    panic!("expected fixture failure");
+                };
+                response.send(Err(error.into_transport_error())).unwrap();
+                let error = tokio::time::timeout(std::time::Duration::from_secs(5), caller)
+                    .await
+                    .unwrap()
+                    .unwrap()
+                    .unwrap_err();
+                assert!(
+                    matches!(
+                        commands.try_recv(),
+                        Err(tokio::sync::mpsc::error::TryRecvError::Empty
+                            | tokio::sync::mpsc::error::TryRecvError::Disconnected)
+                    ),
+                    "must not retry"
+                );
+                let forwarded = WorkdirTransportError::from_workdir_error(&error);
+                assert_eq!(
+                    forwarded.code, expected_code,
+                    "{code:?}, {reason:?}, mutation={mutation}: {error:?}"
+                );
+                assert_eq!(error.denial_reason(), reason);
+                assert_eq!(forwarded.denial_reason, reason);
+                if expected_code == Code::OutcomeUnknown {
+                    assert!(forwarded.message.contains("inspect before retrying"));
+                }
+                let response = InternalWorkdirOperationError::Provider(forwarded).into_response();
+                assert_eq!(response.status().as_u16(), expected_code.http_status());
+                let body = axum::body::to_bytes(response.into_body(), 2048)
+                    .await
+                    .unwrap();
+                let body: serde_json::Value = serde_json::from_slice(&body).unwrap();
+                assert_eq!(body["code"], expected_code.as_str());
+                assert!(body.get("denial_reason").is_none());
+            }
+        }
+    }
+}

docs/development/workdir-refusal-diagnostics.md

@@ -137,6 +137,18 @@ is never parsed into a reason.
   provider: missing files are created identically without/with/nested reasons;
   denied/read-only/conflict/unknown-outcome stat failures never write or retry.
   This protects actual create control flow in addition to error conversion.
+- Real Remote HTTP and channel-backed External session dispatch tests cover
+  Read/Create/Write/Edit crossed with missing/typed reasons and five error codes.
+  After a dispatched mutation, Unavailable/Transport still become OutcomeUnknown
+  with the original reason preserved: forwarded 500 and inspect-before-retry
+  guidance are unchanged. Read and definite refusal/conflict controls retain
+  their existing codes. The External path also checks actual HTTP error body/
+  status conversion and absence of a new dispatch after the failure.
+- Fake-command JSON fixtures cover attachment detach and scoped-command close
+  without launching processes. Missing/typed/nested UnknownCommand all retain
+  disappearance/lease-release semantics. Unavailable remains a busy detach or
+  failed scope cleanup; scope close revokes new work immediately but retains the
+  write lease while cleanup is unresolved. Diagnostic data never grants cleanup.
 - A signed real self-handler test observes command dispatch, then removes only
   its fixture session-registration entry before returning the start handle.
   The 502 remains a post-start `command_registration` failure with a neutral

docs/report/t731-review-verdict-registration-401.md

@@ -68,6 +68,17 @@ The new test fails for the typed-reason case before the fix and passes all three
 forms after it. That source movement still needs fresh exact-source review, not
 reuse of the old review binding. The user-reported Workdir 403 remains unidentified.
 
+## Later registration observation
+
+A subsequent fresh binding on source
+`6ac87c885e58f11cb6dde0557c9229249f2c428e` successfully recorded request-changes:
+MR seq5 event `01a12114-771a-76b1-b0fb-2fde0d56e3e1` at
+`2026-10-09T14:32:31.769486531+00:00`, confirmed by parent MR reread. This proves
+that selected submission succeeded; it does not explain the earlier 401.
+No authentication, proof, capability, Backend, or running binary changes were
+made to obtain it. The remaining code finding and routine review evidence are
+on that MR, not an approval or Ticket conclusion in this report.
+
 ## Improvement proposal
 
 A verdict-registration rejection should expose a safe, bounded internal