## Created Created by LocalTicketBackend create. --- ## Plan ## Intake refinement Readiness: implementation_ready. Binding decisions / invariants: - `investigator` is no longer a fixed Ticket role or configured role slot. The fixed Ticket roles are `intake`, `orchestrator`, `coder`, and `reviewer`. - Investigation remains available only as task-specific helper Pod work launched by Intake/Orchestrator/planning when useful; it must not require a `[roles.investigator]` config entry or a `project:investigator` profile slot. - Existing/current `[roles.investigator]` config must not be silently used as a supported role. The implementation should choose a clear unsupported-config diagnostic or documented migration behavior and keep that behavior test-covered. - Do not reintroduce the removed TUI `:ticket investigate` command or add a generic arbitrary role registry in this cleanup. Implementation latitude: - The implementation may choose the smallest cohesive code shape for removing the enum/config/default/scaffold/test references, including whether compatibility is expressed as an explicit config error or migration note. - Local code mapping and exact test updates are implementation details as long as role launch remains working for intake/orchestrator/coder/reviewer. Reviewer / Orchestrator focus: - Confirm all fixed-role surfaces are removed, not only user-facing docs. - Confirm helper-Pod investigation wording remains possible without implying a configured Ticket role. - Confirm role config failure behavior for stale `[roles.investigator]` is intentional and covered. Risk flags: ticket-config, role-boundary, docs, compatibility. Validation: - Focused tests for `ticket::config`, `client::ticket_role`, and affected TUI/panel role-launch paths. - `target/debug/yoi ticket doctor` - `cargo fmt --check` - `git diff --check` - `nix build .#yoi` if code/package/runtime resources are changed. --- ## Intake summary 既存 Ticket を確認し、`investigator` を固定 Ticket role/config slot から削除する cleanup として要件を同期した。固定 role は `intake` / `orchestrator` / `coder` / `reviewer` のみとし、調査は必要時の task-specific helper Pod として残す。stale `[roles.investigator]` は silently supported にせず、明確な診断または migration として扱う。Orchestrator は実装 routing 可能。risk_flags: ticket-config, role-boundary, docs, compatibility。 --- ## State changed Ticket planning が完了しました。workflow_state planning -> ready。 --- ## State changed Ticket を `workspace-panel` が queued にしました。 --- ## Decision Routing decision: implementation_ready Reason: - Ticket body and thread record the product decision: fixed Ticket role slots are Intake / Orchestrator / Coder / Reviewer, and Investigator is not an official fixed role. - The requested behavior is bounded and observable: remove Investigator from role enum/config/scaffold/prompt/workflow surfaces while preserving ad-hoc read-only investigation as an ordinary Pod/workflow pattern where needed. - Remaining uncertainty is code cleanup/test coverage, not a design-boundary question. Evidence checked: - Ticket body and thread, including queued event. - Workspace state: no matching branch/worktree exists; main workspace is clean before routing. - Code/prompt search for `Investigator`, `investigator`, `roles.investigator`, `project:investigator`, and `ticket investigate` across Ticket role config, client launch, TUI/Panel, profiles, prompts, workflows, and docs. - Ticket doctor: 0 errors; existing warnings are unrelated legacy closed-Ticket diagnostics. IntentPacket: Intent: - Remove the fixed Investigator Ticket role from the product/config/runtime surfaces and keep only the fixed Ticket role slots that are actually supported. Binding decisions / invariants: - Fixed Ticket roles are Intake, Orchestrator, Coder, and Reviewer. - Investigator is not a fixed Ticket role and should not appear in required role config/scaffold/enum/action surfaces. - Ad-hoc investigation remains possible through normal Pods/workflows when a human/Orchestrator explicitly asks for read-only investigation, but it is not a fixed Ticket role slot. - Do not remove generic Pod spawning, peer messaging, or read-only review/investigation capability. - Do not change Ticket workflow-state semantics or the planning/ready/queued/inprogress/done model. - Avoid compatibility aliases that silently keep `investigator` as an official fixed role unless needed only to reject legacy config with a clear diagnostic. Requirements / acceptance criteria: - Remove Investigator from fixed Ticket role enum/config parsing/scaffold/defaults. - Remove project/local profile references for `project:investigator` or equivalent official role config if present and unused. - Remove Panel/TUI/CLI/workflow references that present Investigator as a first-class Ticket role/action. - Update role-launch prompt/config tests to expect only Intake/Orchestrator/Coder/Reviewer fixed slots. - Keep any generic “read-only investigation” language as a task/workflow tactic rather than a fixed role. - Add/update tests so configs requiring only the four fixed roles pass, and legacy/unknown investigator role config is rejected or ignored according to the explicit parser policy. Implementation latitude: - Coder may leave historical Ticket records untouched. - Coder may retain lowercase text such as “investigation” in generic prose if it is not an official role name/action/config surface. - Coder may choose whether legacy `roles.investigator` is rejected as unknown or treated as ignored-with-diagnostic if existing config parser has such a policy; report the decision. - Coder may update docs/workflows narrowly where they refer to fixed roles. Escalate if: - Removing Investigator requires a broader generic role registry redesign. - Existing role config parser cannot reject/ignore extra role tables without changing config compatibility policy. - Panel/CLI surfaces depend on Investigator for a still-supported action that needs a replacement design. Validation: - Focused client/ticket-role config tests. - TUI/Panel tests if action lists or role displays change. - Profile/scaffold tests for `.yoi/ticket.config.toml` generation. - Search maintained code/prompts/workflows/docs for official Investigator role references. - `cargo fmt --check`. - `git diff --check`. - `cargo run -q -p yoi -- ticket doctor`. - Because role config/profile/prompt/workflow surfaces may change, final merge-completion should include `nix build .#yoi`. Current code map: - `crates/client/src/ticket_role.rs`: fixed role enum/config/launcher/prompt handling. - `crates/tui/src/multi_pod.rs` / `workspace_panel.rs`: Panel action/role launch surfaces. - `crates/yoi/src/ticket_cli.rs`: ticket init/scaffold/config tests. - `.yoi/profiles` and profile registry/resources for role profile selectors. - `.yoi/workflow/*.md`, `docs/development/*.md`, and `resources/prompts` for fixed-role wording. Critical risks / reviewer focus: - Do not remove Intake role just because workflow state no longer uses `intake` as a state. - Ensure Orchestrator/Coder/Reviewer role launches still work. - Ensure scaffolded Ticket config remains executable and concrete. - Ensure no maintained prompt/workflow still implies an official Investigator role slot. - Avoid broad docs churn outside role-surface cleanup. --- ## State changed Accepted queued implementation after reading the Ticket, workspace state, and fixed-role code map. This acceptance precedes worktree creation and coder/reviewer Pod spawning. --- ## Plan Implementation routing accepted and worktree created. Worktree plan: - Branch: `remove-fixed-investigator-ticket-role` - Worktree: `.worktree/remove-fixed-investigator-ticket-role` - Base: `dc65b7d ticket: route investigator role cleanup` - Scope: remove fixed Investigator Ticket role from role config/scaffold/runtime/prompt/workflow/doc surfaces while preserving generic read-only investigation as an ad-hoc tactic. Delegation plan: - Spawn sibling coder Pod with write scope limited to `.worktree/remove-fixed-investigator-ticket-role`. - Coder should run commands from the child worktree. The live Orchestrator may not expose `SpawnPod.cwd` until restart, so the task packet uses explicit `cd` instructions. - Coder must not edit main-workspace `.yoi` / Ticket / workflow / docs records, and must not create generated memory/local/runtime/secret-like files. - Reviewer will be spawned read-only after coder reports diff/commits and validation evidence. Dirty-state note: - Main workspace has unrelated Ticket-record edits/untracked Ticket records. This implementation is isolated in the child worktree and must not edit those records. Stop/completion policy: - Because the human authorized cleanup after completion, this Orchestrator will proceed through reviewer approval, merge-completion validation, Ticket close, Pod stop, worktree removal, and branch deletion if the branch is approved and merge authority remains clear. --- ## Implementation report Implementation delegation blocked after inprogress acceptance. What succeeded: - Transitioned Ticket from `queued` to `inprogress` before implementation side effects. - Created branch/worktree `remove-fixed-investigator-ticket-role` at `.worktree/remove-fixed-investigator-ticket-role`. Blocker: - Spawning sibling coder Pod failed because this live Orchestrator was started before/without the newly explicit delegation grant: - error: `SpawnPod requires delegation authority, but this Pod has no delegation scope grant; direct filesystem scope only authorizes this Pod's own tools` Current state: - No coder/reviewer Pods were spawned. - No implementation edits have been made in the worktree. - The Ticket remains `inprogress` because routing acceptance and worktree creation already happened; this is now a delegation-scope recovery issue. Next recovery options: - Restore/relaunch an Orchestrator with explicit delegation authority for this workspace and continue by spawning the coder with narrow worktree write scope. - Or explicitly authorize this Orchestrator to implement directly in the child worktree, though that would bypass the sibling coder/reviewer workflow and should be treated as a separate instruction. No merge, close, final approval, or cleanup has occurred. --- ## Implementation report Delegation recovery succeeded after Orchestrator relaunch. Spawned sibling Coder Pod: - Pod: `coder-remove-fixed-investigator-ticket-role` - Worktree: `.worktree/remove-fixed-investigator-ticket-role` - Scope: read access to workspace root entry plus write access limited to the child worktree. The first spawn attempt still failed because the child startup checked the parent workspace `pwd`; the retry added a non-recursive read grant on `/home/hare/Projects/yoi` while keeping write authority limited to the worktree. --- ## Implementation report Coder implementation completed and was handed to sibling Reviewer. Coder Pod: - `coder-remove-fixed-investigator-ticket-role` - Commit: `427a270 ticket: remove fixed investigator role` - Worktree status before review: clean branch `remove-fixed-investigator-ticket-role` - Stopped after collecting output to reclaim delegated worktree scope. Reviewer Pod: - `reviewer-remove-fixed-investigator-ticket-role` - Reviewing commit `427a270` against the fixed-role removal invariants. Orchestrator pre-review evidence: changed files are limited to Ticket role config/CLI plus workflow/docs wording; a quick scoped search found remaining investigator references only in expected test/migration-note contexts. --- ## Review: approve Reviewed commit `427a270` (`ticket: remove fixed investigator role`) on branch `remove-fixed-investigator-ticket-role` in worktree `/home/hare/Projects/yoi/.worktree/remove-fixed-investigator-ticket-role`. Evidence: - `TicketRole::ALL` is now only `intake`, `orchestrator`, `coder`, `reviewer`; no `TicketRole::Investigator` remains in the active role model. - Ticket config loading rejects unknown role tables by parsing `[roles.*]` keys through `TicketRole::parse`; the added `stale_investigator_role_config_is_rejected` test checks `[roles.investigator]` fails with `unsupported Ticket role \`investigator\`` and lists supported roles. - Config scaffold / `yoi ticket init` assertions now check `[roles.investigator]` is absent while the four remaining role tables are present. - Maintained docs/workflows no longer present `investigator` as a fixed role or config slot. Remaining maintained references are the intentional migration note and tests. Historical Ticket records still contain old text, which is audit history rather than maintained docs. - Orchestrator/planning wording still permits task-specific read-only helper Pods for investigation (`task-specific helper Pod`, `read-only investigation helper Pod`, and `spike_needed -> read-only investigation plan / Pod`). - No TUI `:ticket investigate` path or generic arbitrary role registry was reintroduced; `intake` remains a fixed role. Validation run by reviewer: - `cargo test -p ticket config` - `cargo test -p client ticket_role` - `cargo test -p yoi ticket_cli_init` - `cargo test -p tui workspace_panel` - `cargo test -p tui multi_ticket_intake` - `cargo fmt --check` - `git diff --check` - `cargo run -q -p yoi -- ticket doctor` - `cargo check --workspace` - `nix build .#yoi --no-link` Result: approve. No required changes found. --- ## State changed Ticket closed; workflow_state を done に設定しました。 --- ## 完了 Implemented and merged. Summary: - Removed `investigator` from the fixed Ticket role set; remaining fixed roles are `intake`, `orchestrator`, `coder`, and `reviewer`. - Updated Ticket config parsing and scaffold tests so `[roles.investigator]` is not emitted and stale `[roles.investigator]` config is rejected with a clear unsupported-role diagnostic. - Updated role docs/workflow wording so investigation remains an optional task-specific helper Pod tactic rather than a configured fixed Ticket role. - Preserved `intake` and existing planning/ready/queued/inprogress/done workflow semantics. Implementation: - Coder commit: `427a270 ticket: remove fixed investigator role` - Merge commit: `b552372 merge: remove fixed investigator ticket role` - Reviewer: approved by `reviewer-remove-fixed-investigator-ticket-role`. Validation: - Coder/reviewer focused role/config/panel tests passed. - Post-merge validation passed: - `cargo fmt --check` - `git diff --check` - `cargo run -q -p yoi -- ticket doctor` - `cargo check --workspace` - `nix build .#yoi` ---