Hare/yoi
1
1
Fork 0
Code Actions Packages Releases Activity
develop
yoi/.yoi/tickets/00001KTVPS6K3/thread.md

22 KiB
Raw Permalink Blame History

作成

LocalTicketBackend によって作成されました。

Intake summary

Ticket role launch の初回 user message を短縮し、情報所管を Instruction / Workflow / Submit / control-plane に分離する方針で合意済み。language と workspace_root/cwd は Instruction 側の環境情報、Git/worktree 操作対象として必要な path は Submit に重複記載可。workflow slug/profile selector は初回 user message に含めない。

State changed

要件・受け入れ条件・境界判断が揃ったため、Orchestrator routing 可能。実装はユーザーが panel で queue した後に開始する。

Decision

Routing decision: blocked_by_dependency_or_missing_authority

Reason:

  • Workspace Panel Queue notification was received, but this Orchestrator backend still reads the Ticket as ready, not queued.
  • The root workspace has unsynced/uncommitted queue-related changes for this Ticket and is dirty, including .yoi/tickets/00001KTVPS6K3/* and crates/tui/src/multi_pod.rs.
  • Active in-progress work 00001KTWPE3KQ is currently fixing the Panel Queue durable handoff/sync path and is in reviewer handoff; accepting this new Ticket before that path is reviewed/merged would require manual sync/queue recovery and could mix queue-side effects with unrelated dirty root changes.

Evidence checked:

  • TicketShow 00001KTVPS6K3: Orchestrator backend state is ready.
  • TicketRelationQuery: no relation blockers.
  • TicketOrchestrationPlanQuery: no prior plan records before this routing note.
  • Root/orchestrator git state: Orchestrator branch has local routing record changes; root workspace is dirty with this Ticket's .yoi files and crates/tui/src/multi_pod.rs.
  • Visible Pods: active reviewer yoi-reviewer-panel-queue-sync for 00001KTWPE3KQ.

Next action:

  • Leave this Ticket unaccepted for implementation in this Orchestrator pass.
  • Re-route after the Panel Queue durable handoff work is resolved and the root/orchestration Ticket state is synchronized cleanly, or after a human explicitly instructs manual recovery for the queued root-side changes.

Escalate if:

  • The queued root-side changes should be manually committed/synced despite the current dirty workspace and active Queue-handoff fix.

State changed

Ticket を workspace-panel が queued にしました。

Decision

Routing decision: implementation_ready

Reason:

  • Ticket body は Ticket role launch の first-run user message から role behavior / procedural guidance / control-plane metadata を外し、Submit に対象 Ticket / action instruction / per-launch context だけを残す方針を明確に記録している。
  • Instruction / Workflow / Submit / control-plane の境界、Ticket config schema に instruction field を追加しないこと、launch context template 化を避けることが binding decision として記録済みである。
  • ready -> queued は workspace-panel により再実行され、現在の Orchestrator backend でも queued として読める。relation blocker はない。
  • 以前の blocker だった Panel Queue durable handoff work 00001KTWPE3KQ は closed 済みで、現在の orchestration worktree は clean。残る不確実性は既存 prompt/profile/workflow resource と crates/client/src/ticket_role.rs 周辺の bounded implementation investigation に閉じている。

Evidence checked:

  • Ticket body / thread / artifacts: item.md、thread.md、既存 waiting-capacity note を確認。
  • TicketRelationQuery: outgoing/incoming relation なし、blocker なし。
  • TicketOrchestrationPlanQuery: 既存 waiting_capacity_note と、今回の accepted plan orch-plan-20260612-123134-2 を確認。
  • Related Ticket: 00001KTWPE3KQ は closed 済みで、Queue handoff blocker は解消済み。
  • Workspace state: Orchestrator worktree orchestration/yoi-orchestrator は clean。
  • Code/resource map: crates/client/src/ticket_role.rs, resources/profiles/orchestrator.lua, resources/prompts/ticket_role/*.md と関連 prompt/profile/workflow resource を確認。
  • Durable context: prompt prose は resources/prompts へ集約し、Profile/Workflow が role behavior/procedure を所有する既存方針に一致する。
  • Visible Pods: active child Pod なし。

IntentPacket:

Intent:

  • Ticket role Pod launch の初回 user message を短縮し、model-visible な launch input を Submit-only の per-launch context に近づける。
  • role behavior は builtin role Profile が選ぶ Instruction、procedural guidance は Workflow、control-plane metadata は launch plan/diagnostics/trace に分離する。

Binding decisions / invariants:

  • Profile selector、Workflow、Configured launch_prompt ref などの control-plane metadata は first-run user message に含めない。
  • role behavior / 恒常的環境情報 / language / workspace_root / cwd は Instruction/system 側の責務とする。ただし今回の Git/worktree 操作対象として必要な path は Submit に明示してよい。
  • procedural guidance は Workflow 側に置く。
  • Submit に残す情報は対象 Ticket、action instruction、今回の操作対象として必要な per-launch context に限定する。
  • Ticket config に role-level system_instruction / instruction field を追加しない。
  • launch context の過剰なテンプレート化は行わず、Rust 側の短い Submit 組み立てに留める。
  • 新しい input を hidden context として差し込まず、必要な model-visible context は適切な Instruction/Workflow/committed user task/history 経由にする。

Requirements / acceptance criteria:

  • Ticket role launch の first-run Segment::Text が短くなり、対象 Ticket / action instruction / per-launch context だけを含む。
  • role behavior は builtin role instruction prompt から供給される。
  • procedural guidance は Workflow に残る、または Workflow に移されている。
  • control-plane metadata は prompt text ではなく launch plan / diagnostics / trace に留まる。
  • Ticket record language guidance は first-run user message ではなく Instruction 側の環境情報として扱われる。
  • Orchestrator launch で必要な workspace/cwd/topology 情報は Pod 環境情報と per-operation Submit 情報に分離され、Git/worktree 操作対象として必要なものだけ Submit 内で明示される。
  • 関連 unit tests が新しい出力方針を検証する。
  • nix build .#yoi が通る。

Implementation latitude:

  • builtin role instruction prompt のファイル名・配置は既存 prompt resource conventions に合わせて選んでよい。
  • resources/prompts/ticket_role の既存 fragment は、不要なら削除または縮小してよい。
  • TicketRoleLaunchContext.user_instruction rename は、変更量が大きい場合は段階的移行でもよい。ただし model-visible label は User/action instruction より正確な名前にする。
  • Workflow 側に移す文言は public builtin workflow と workspace dogfood workflow の責務差を保つ。

Escalate if:

  • Instruction / Workflow / Submit の境界に収まらない新しい model-visible 情報が見つかる。
  • Ticket role launch の dynamic data を Instruction minijinja context に入れる必要が出る。
  • Ticket config schema に新しい instruction field を追加する必要が出る。
  • Workflow invocation、workspace/user prompt override、Ticket role launch、Panel Intake / Orchestrator launch のいずれかを壊さないと実現できない。

Validation:

  • Ticket role launch prompt 出力の unit tests。
  • builtin role Profile が instruction prompt を解決できることの focused validation。
  • relevant cargo tests。
  • cargo fmt --check。
  • git diff --check。
  • target/debug/yoi ticket doctor または built binary の yoi ticket doctor。
  • nix build .#yoi。

Current code map:

  • 主対象: crates/client/src/ticket_role.rs。
  • Profile/resource: resources/profiles/{intake,orchestrator,coder,reviewer}.lua, resources/prompts/ticket_role/*.md, 必要な resources/workflows/* / .yoi/workflow/*。
  • Prompt/system integration check: crates/pod/src/prompt/system.rs。
  • Implementation worktree では Orchestrator/main .yoi records、.yoi/memory、local/runtime/log/lock/secret-like .yoi paths を生成・編集しない。

Critical risks / reviewer focus:

  • control-plane metadata が first-run user message に残っていないこと。
  • role behavior / procedure が Submit に残留せず、Instruction / Workflow の適切な boundary に移っていること。
  • Ticket record language guidance と workspace/cwd/topology 情報が hidden/ephemeral context injection になっていないこと。
  • Dynamic Ticket data を system Instruction 側へ混ぜないこと。
  • 既存 Ticket role launch、Panel Intake/Orchestrator launch、workflow invocation、prompt override の動作を壊していないこと。

Next action:

  • queued -> inprogress を記録してから、branch ticket/shorten-ticket-role-launch-input / worktree /home/hare/Projects/yoi/.worktree/shorten-ticket-role-launch-input を作成し、sibling coder に narrow write scope で実装を委譲する。Reviewer は coder evidence 後に read-only で起動する。

State changed

Routing accepted for implementation. Ticket body/thread, relation blockers, orchestration plan, prior waiting-capacity note, closed Queue-handoff dependency, current Orchestrator workspace state, relevant prompt/profile/workflow code map, and visible Pods were rechecked. No unresolved blocker or missing planning decision remains. Implementation side effects will start only after this accepted queued -> inprogress transition is recorded, using accepted plan orch-plan-20260612-123134-2.

Plan

Implementation worktree created for multi-agent handoff.

  • Ticket: 00001KTVPS6K3
  • Branch: ticket/shorten-ticket-role-launch-input
  • Worktree: /home/hare/Projects/yoi/.worktree/shorten-ticket-role-launch-input
  • Base: Orchestrator workspace HEAD ae66c447 (orchestration/yoi-orchestrator), including the accepted routing record and queued -> inprogress transition.
  • Scope rule: implementation work happens only in this child worktree. Root/original workspace must not be read, written, validated, merged, cleaned, or used for git operations.
  • Next: spawn sibling coder with narrow write scope to the implementation worktree. Reviewer will be started after coder evidence is available.

Implementation report

Coder spawn initial attempt failed before socket creation.

  • Coder Pod name: yoi-coder-role-launch-input
  • Error: cwd is not readable under the configured scope: /home/hare/Projects/yoi
  • Recovery: retry with the same child worktree write scope plus minimal non-recursive read authority on the runtime workspace root required by spawn validation. The coder task still explicitly prohibits reading/writing/validating/merging/cleaning/running git in the root/original workspace and must operate from the child worktree only.

Plan

Coder delegated.

  • Coder Pod: yoi-coder-role-launch-input
  • Worktree: /home/hare/Projects/yoi/.worktree/shorten-ticket-role-launch-input
  • Branch: ticket/shorten-ticket-role-launch-input
  • Scope: write /home/hare/Projects/yoi/.worktree/shorten-ticket-role-launch-input; read child worktree plus minimal non-recursive runtime-root read required by spawn validation.
  • Task: shorten Ticket role launch first-run Submit input, move/keep role behavior in builtin Profile instruction, keep procedural guidance in Workflow, keep control-plane metadata out of first-run user text, add focused tests, validate with relevant cargo tests and nix build .#yoi.
  • Constraint: coder was instructed not to use root/original workspace for decision evidence or git/validation/cleanup, and not to create generated memory/local/runtime/log/lock/secret-like .yoi paths.

Implementation report

Coder completed implementation.

Coder Pod:

  • yoi-coder-role-launch-input

Implementation branch/worktree:

  • Branch: ticket/shorten-ticket-role-launch-input
  • Worktree: /home/hare/Projects/yoi/.worktree/shorten-ticket-role-launch-input
  • Commit: 949531a0 client: shorten ticket role launch input
  • Worktree status: clean

Changed surfaces:

  • crates/client/src/ticket_role.rs
  • crates/manifest/src/profile.rs
  • crates/pod/src/prompt/loader.rs
  • resources/profiles/{intake,orchestrator,coder,reviewer}.lua
  • resources/prompts/role/{intake,orchestrator,coder,reviewer}.md
  • removed obsolete resources/prompts/ticket_role/*.md
  • resources/workflows/{multi-agent-workflow,ticket-intake-workflow,ticket-orchestrator-routing}.md

Orchestrator-verified evidence from child worktree:

  • git status --short --branch clean on ticket/shorten-ticket-role-launch-input
  • cargo test -p client ticket_role --lib: pass, 16 tests
  • cargo test -p manifest builtin_role_profiles_are_registered_and_resolve --lib: pass, 1 test
  • cargo test -p pod builtin_ticket_role_instructions_resolve --lib: pass, 1 test
  • cargo fmt --check: pass
  • git diff --check orchestration/yoi-orchestrator...HEAD: pass
  • ./result/bin/yoi ticket doctor: doctor: ok
  • nix build .#yoi: pass

Next:

  • Spawn read-only sibling reviewer against the recorded intent, binding decisions/invariants, acceptance criteria, commit 949531a0, diff, and validation evidence.

Plan

Reviewer delegated.

  • Reviewer Pod: yoi-reviewer-role-launch-input
  • Target branch/worktree: ticket/shorten-ticket-role-launch-input at /home/hare/Projects/yoi/.worktree/shorten-ticket-role-launch-input
  • Commit under review: 949531a0 client: shorten ticket role launch input
  • Scope: read-only child worktree plus minimal non-recursive runtime-root read required by spawn validation.
  • Review basis: recorded IntentPacket, binding decisions/invariants, acceptance criteria, implementation summary, diff, and Orchestrator-verified validation evidence.
  • Reviewer focus: control-plane metadata absence from first-run user text, Instruction/Workflow/Submit boundary, no hidden dynamic context injection, profile instruction resolution, workflow/prompt override safety, and non-brittle tests.

Review: approve

Approve.

Review target:

  • Worktree: /home/hare/Projects/yoi/.worktree/shorten-ticket-role-launch-input
  • Commit: 949531a07ede4fd9f82787454ac4d996f25b272d
  • Worktree status: clean

Evidence:

  • crates/client/src/ticket_role.rs の first-run Segment::Text は build_launch_prompt で対象 Ticket、Action instruction、Panel handoff、intent packet、operation/worktree target、validation/report expectations に限定されている。
  • profile / workflow / launch_prompt_ref / workspace-root 系の制御情報は TicketRoleLaunchPlan / SpawnConfig 側に残り、Submit text には出ていない。
  • WorkflowInvoke は Segment::WorkflowInvoke として別 segment に維持されている。
  • unit tests は Configured launch_prompt、Profile selector、Workflow:、Ticket record language、role_workspace_root / role_cwd 等が first-run text に入らないことと、必要な path/branch/validation/report expectation が残ることを直接検証している。
  • builtin role Profiles は worker.instruction = "$yoi/role/<role>" を設定し、resources/prompts/role/* に role behavior が移っている。procedural guidance は resources/workflows/* に残っている。
  • 削除された resources/prompts/ticket_role/* への production code 参照は残っていない。prompt loader の $user / $workspace 解決機構と workflow invocation は維持されている。
  • git diff --check orchestration/yoi-orchestrator...HEAD は問題なし。Orchestrator が提示した focused cargo tests、cargo fmt --check、ticket doctor、nix build .#yoi の validation evidence は受け入れ可能。

Non-blocking risk:

  • 旧 .yoi/prompts/ticket_role/* override は、この surface の削除により launch Submit text には効かなくなる。今回の Ticket では既存 fragment の削除が許容されているため blocker ではないが、外部ユーザー向けには role behavior は Profile instruction、手順は Workflow override へ移す旨を後で案内すると安全。

Implementation report

Integration completed in the Orchestrator workspace.

Integrated implementation:

  • Ticket: 00001KTVPS6K3
  • Implementation branch: ticket/shorten-ticket-role-launch-input
  • Implementation commit: 949531a0 client: shorten ticket role launch input
  • Reviewer result: approve, no blockers
  • Orchestrator merge commit: bdbd955b merge: ticket role launch input split
  • Integration target: orchestration/yoi-orchestrator

Post-integration validation from Orchestrator worktree:

  • cargo test -p client ticket_role --lib: pass, 16 tests
  • cargo test -p manifest builtin_role_profiles_are_registered_and_resolve --lib: pass, 1 test
  • cargo test -p pod builtin_ticket_role_instructions_resolve --lib: pass, 1 test
  • cargo fmt --check: pass
  • git diff --check HEAD~1..HEAD: pass
  • nix build .#yoi: pass
  • ./result/bin/yoi ticket doctor: doctor: ok

Remaining non-blocking risk:

  • 旧 .yoi/prompts/ticket_role/* override は launch Submit text には効かなくなる。今回の Ticket では fragment 削除が許容されているため blocker ではないが、外部ユーザー向けには role behavior は Profile instruction、手順は Workflow override へ移す旨を後続で案内すると安全。

State changed

Implementation was merged into the Orchestrator branch, reviewer approved, and post-integration validation passed. Cleanup and closure will be recorded next.

Implementation report

Cleanup completed.

  • Stopped coder Pod: yoi-coder-role-launch-input
  • Stopped reviewer Pod: yoi-reviewer-role-launch-input
  • Removed child worktree: /home/hare/Projects/yoi/.worktree/shorten-ticket-role-launch-input
  • Deleted implementation branch: ticket/shorten-ticket-role-launch-input
  • Orchestrator worktree status after cleanup: clean

Cleanup was limited to child implementation worktree/branch and related child Pods. Root/original workspace was not touched.

State changed

Ticket を closed にしました。

完了

Ticket role launch の first-run user message を短縮し、role behavior / procedural guidance / control-plane metadata の所管を分離した。

実装概要:

  • crates/client/src/ticket_role.rs の launch Submit text を短縮し、対象 Ticket / action instruction / per-launch context に限定した。
  • Profile selector、Workflow、Configured launch_prompt ref、Ticket record language guidance、runtime workspace/cwd などの control-plane / environment 情報を first-run user text から外した。
  • builtin role Profiles に worker.instruction = "$yoi/role/<role>" を設定し、role behavior を resources/prompts/role/{intake,orchestrator,coder,reviewer}.md へ移した。
  • procedural guidance は Workflow resources 側に保持・移動した。
  • obsolete な resources/prompts/ticket_role/*.md fragments を削除した。
  • boundary を検証する focused unit tests を追加・更新した。

Review / integration:

  • Implementation commit: 949531a0 client: shorten ticket role launch input
  • Reviewer: yoi-reviewer-role-launch-input が approve。
  • Orchestrator merge commit: bdbd955b merge: ticket role launch input split
  • Ticket completion commit: 9ad5ed6d ticket: mark role launch done

Validation:

  • cargo test -p client ticket_role --lib: pass
  • cargo test -p manifest builtin_role_profiles_are_registered_and_resolve --lib: pass
  • cargo test -p pod builtin_ticket_role_instructions_resolve --lib: pass
  • cargo fmt --check: pass
  • git diff --check HEAD~1..HEAD: pass
  • nix build .#yoi: pass
  • ./result/bin/yoi ticket doctor: doctor: ok

Cleanup:

  • coder/reviewer Pods stopped。
  • child worktree /home/hare/Projects/yoi/.worktree/shorten-ticket-role-launch-input removed。
  • branch ticket/shorten-ticket-role-launch-input deleted。

Non-blocking follow-up:

  • 旧 .yoi/prompts/ticket_role/* override は launch Submit text には効かなくなるため、外部ユーザー向けには role behavior は Profile instruction、手順は Workflow override へ移す旨を必要に応じて案内すると安全。