Hare/yoi
1
1
Fork 0
Code Actions Packages Releases Activity
develop
yoi/.yoi/tickets/00001KTWPE3KQ/thread.md

16 KiB
Raw Permalink Blame History

作成

LocalTicketBackend によって作成されました。

Intake summary

Marked ready by yoi ticket state.

State changed

Marked ready by yoi ticket state.

State changed

Ticket を yoi ticket が queued にしました。

Decision

Routing decision: implementation_ready

Reason:

  • Ticket body は Panel Queue action の目的、binding invariants、失敗時の block 条件、非目標、受け入れ条件を observable に記録している。
  • ready -> queued は既に記録済みで、relation blocker はない。
  • 設計境界は「Ticket tools は cwd 基準」「Panel は root/dev 側の Queue commit を authority とし、Orchestrator kick 前に orchestration worktree を ff-only sync する」「自動 conflict resolution / stash / rebase はしない」として十分に固定されている。
  • 残る不確実性は既存 Panel/Ticket/git helper 実装への bounded implementation investigation と local tactic selection に閉じている。

Evidence checked:

  • Ticket body / thread / artifacts: 00001KTWPE3KQ の本文、state/event、artifact なしを確認。
  • TicketRelationQuery: outgoing/incoming relation なし、blocker なし。
  • TicketOrchestrationPlanQuery: 既存 record なし。今回 orch-plan-20260612-084329-1 として accepted plan を記録。
  • Workspace state: Orchestrator worktree は ## ticket/orchestrator-progress-companion-notify、root workspace は ## develop、どちらも dirty 出力なし。
  • Code map: crates/tui/src/workspace_panel.rs と crates/tui/src/multi_pod.rs 周辺に Panel Queue / workspace panel / orchestrator launch の実装面があることを確認。
  • Visible Pods: 現在 visible Pod はこの Orchestrator のみで、coder/reviewer は未起動。

IntentPacket:

Intent:

  • Panel Queue action を、root/dev 側の ready -> queued commit と orchestration worktree への ff-only sync を完了してから Orchestrator notify/kick する durable handoff にする。

Binding decisions / invariants:

  • root workspace の canonical top-level、orchestration worktree の canonical top-level、共通 git dir、期待 branch、dirty 状態、対象 Ticket の ready 状態、orchestration_head が root_head の ancestor であることを mutation 前に検証する。
  • Queue commit は root/dev 側で対象 Ticket record だけを stage/commit する。
  • orchestration worktree への自動同期は git -C <orchestration_worktree> merge --ff-only <queue_commit_sha> のみに限定する。
  • merge commit、rebase、stash、patch apply、conflict resolution、dirty cleanup は Panel Queue action では行わない。
  • Orchestrator notify/restore/kick は orchestration worktree HEAD が Queue commit を含み、orchestration worktree 側 Ticket backend で対象 Ticket が queued として読めることを確認した後だけ行う。
  • Ticket tools が cwd 基準で動く設計と、workspace_root / cwd / orchestration worktree / merge target の分離を崩さない。

Requirements / acceptance criteria:

  • Queue 成功時、Panel は queued Ticket id、dev 側 Queue commit sha、orchestration worktree sync 結果、Orchestrator notify/kick の有無を表示する。
  • root dirty、orchestration dirty、branch divergence、non-ff sync required、Ticket state mismatch、worktree identity mismatch では Queue を block し、失敗した check 名と対象 path / branch / Ticket id を表示する。
  • nix build .#yoi が通る。

Implementation latitude:

  • 既存 Panel action / Git helper / Ticket backend 呼び出しのどこへ checks と sync 処理を分割するかは coder が調査して選んでよい。
  • 表示文言や内部 helper 名は、失敗条件が具体的に伝わり、既存 UX と整合する範囲で調整してよい。
  • Focused tests / unit coverage の追加位置は既存の TUI/client/test 構造に合わせてよい。

Escalate if:

  • Queue action が root/dev 側 Ticket commit 以外の変更を commit/stage する必要が出る。
  • ff-only 以外の sync、stash/rebase/conflict resolution、dirty cleanup を自動化しないと成立しない。
  • Ticket tools の cwd 基準設計、Pod workspace_root/cwd 分離、dedicated Orchestrator worktree の authority boundary を変える必要が出る。
  • Panel が Orchestrator routing/acceptance を代行する必要が出る。

Validation:

  • 変更に対応する focused test / existing relevant cargo test。
  • cargo fmt --check。
  • git diff --check。
  • target/debug/yoi ticket doctor。
  • runtime resource / packaging / prompt へ触れる場合、または最終確認として nix build .#yoi。

Current code map:

  • 主な調査対象: crates/tui/src/workspace_panel.rs, crates/tui/src/multi_pod.rs。
  • Ticket backend / state mutation / CLI helper を変更する場合は crates/ticket と crates/yoi 側の既存 typed Ticket path に合わせる。
  • Orchestrator/main .yoi project records、memory/local/runtime/secret-like .yoi paths は implementation worktree 側で勝手に生成・編集しない。

Critical risks / reviewer focus:

  • root workspace と orchestration worktree を取り違えないこと。
  • dirty/divergent 状態で mutation/commit/notify しないこと。
  • Queue commit の差分が対象 Ticket record 以外へ広がらないこと。
  • ff-only 限定を破らないこと。
  • notify/kick が sync 完了前に走らないこと。
  • cwd 基準 Ticket tools と workspace_root 分離を壊さないこと。

Next action:

  • 今回の launch instruction は role Pod spawn を explicit follow-up まで待つ指定なので、ここでは queued -> inprogress、worktree 作成、coder/reviewer spawn、merge/close は行わない。
  • 明示 follow-up があれば、side effect 前に TicketShow / relation / orchestration plan / git/worktree state を再確認し、問題がなければ queued -> inprogress を記録してから multi-agent-workflow に接続する。

State changed

Routing accepted for implementation. Ticket body/thread, relation blockers, orchestration plan, visible Pods, and root/orchestration git state were rechecked. No unresolved dependency/blocker or missing planning decision was found. Implementation side effects will start only after this accepted queued -> inprogress transition is recorded; worktree and sibling coder/reviewer routing will use the accepted plan orch-plan-20260612-084329-1.

Plan

Implementation worktree created for multi-agent handoff.

  • Ticket: 00001KTWPE3KQ
  • Branch: ticket/panel-queue-orchestrator-sync
  • Worktree: /home/hare/Projects/yoi/.worktree/panel-queue-orchestrator-sync
  • Base: Orchestrator workspace HEAD de0f533b (orchestration/yoi-orchestrator), including the accepted routing record and queued -> inprogress transition.
  • Next: spawn sibling coder with narrow write scope to the implementation worktree. Reviewer will be started after coder evidence is available.

Plan

Coder delegated.

  • Coder Pod: yoi-coder-panel-queue-sync
  • Worktree: /home/hare/Projects/yoi/.worktree/panel-queue-orchestrator-sync
  • Branch: ticket/panel-queue-orchestrator-sync
  • Scope: read /home/hare/Projects/yoi, write /home/hare/Projects/yoi/.worktree/panel-queue-orchestrator-sync
  • Task: implement Panel Queue durable handoff with root/dev Queue commit, orchestration worktree ff-only sync, post-sync Ticket verification, and notify/kick ordering. Coder was instructed not to edit Orchestrator/main .yoi records or generated memory/runtime/secret-like paths.

Implementation report

Coder completed initial implementation.

  • Coder Pod: yoi-coder-panel-queue-sync
  • Implementation branch: ticket/panel-queue-orchestrator-sync
  • Implementation commit: 04a3c6e0 (tui: make panel queue handoff durable)
  • Worktree status checked clean.

Orchestrator validation performed after coder handoff:

  • git diff --check HEAD^..HEAD — pass
  • cargo test -p tui ticket_queue_action -- --nocapture — pass
  • cargo fmt --check — pass
  • cargo check -p tui --all-targets — pass
  • nix build .#yoi — pass
  • ./result/bin/yoi ticket doctor — doctor: ok

Next: delegate independent reviewer against the recorded Ticket intent, accepted plan, implementation commit, and validation evidence.

Plan

Reviewer delegated.

  • Reviewer Pod: yoi-reviewer-panel-queue-sync
  • Review target: /home/hare/Projects/yoi/.worktree/panel-queue-orchestrator-sync, branch ticket/panel-queue-orchestrator-sync, commit 04a3c6e0
  • Scope: read-only /home/hare/Projects/yoi
  • Reviewer focus: durable Queue handoff ordering, root/orchestration worktree identity and cleanliness checks, ff-only-only sync, pathscope of Queue commit, no auto conflict/stash/rebase, notify only after sync + Ticket verification, and whether --no-verify is acceptable.

Implementation report

Merge-ready dossier (human/parent merge authority required before merge/close/cleanup)

Ticket:

  • 00001KTWPE3KQ — Panel Queue時にdevとOrchestrator worktreeを同期する

Branch / worktree:

  • Branch: ticket/panel-queue-orchestrator-sync
  • Worktree: /home/hare/Projects/yoi/.worktree/panel-queue-orchestrator-sync
  • Implementation commit: 04a3c6e0 (tui: make panel queue handoff durable)

Intent / invariant check:

  • Panel Queue action is now implemented as root/dev-side Ticket ready -> queued mutation plus Queue commit, ff-only sync into the dedicated orchestration worktree, then Orchestrator notify/kick only after sync and Ticket-state verification.
  • Automatic sync path is constrained to git -C <orchestration_worktree> merge --ff-only <queue_commit_sha>.
  • No automatic merge commit, rebase, stash, patch apply, conflict resolution, or dirty cleanup path was found.
  • Runtime workspace root / cwd / orchestration worktree / merge target separation remains path-explicit.

Implementation summary:

  • crates/tui/src/multi_pod.rs changed.
  • Added Panel Queue preflight for root/orchestration Git identity, branch state, shared common dir, clean worktrees, root Ticket ready state, and orchestration-head ancestry.
  • Added root-side Queue commit creation scoped to the target Ticket record.
  • Added ff-only orchestration worktree sync and post-sync verification that orchestration HEAD contains the Queue commit and orchestration Ticket backend reads the Ticket as queued.
  • Added focused tests for successful Queue handoff, dirty root blocking, and orchestration branch divergence blocking.

Coder evidence:

  • Coder Pod: yoi-coder-panel-queue-sync
  • Commit: 04a3c6e0
  • Coder reported cargo fmt --check, cargo check -p tui, cargo test -p tui ticket_queue_action -- --nocapture, git diff --check, nix build .#yoi, and ./result/bin/yoi ticket doctor passed. Full cargo test -p tui had unrelated existing failures reported by coder.

Orchestrator validation evidence:

  • git diff --check HEAD^..HEAD — pass
  • cargo test -p tui ticket_queue_action -- --nocapture — pass
  • cargo fmt --check — pass
  • cargo check -p tui --all-targets — pass
  • nix build .#yoi — pass
  • ./result/bin/yoi ticket doctor — doctor: ok

Reviewer evidence:

  • Reviewer Pod: yoi-reviewer-panel-queue-sync
  • Verdict: approve.
  • Reviewer reran git diff --check HEAD^..HEAD and cargo test -p tui ticket_queue_action -- --nocapture; both passed.
  • Reviewer found pre-mutation checks, root-side mutation/commit, ff-only sync, notify-after-verify ordering, path-explicit workspace separation, and failure-message specificity acceptable.
  • Reviewer did not treat --no-verify as a blocker for the automatic target-Ticket-record metadata commit; noted the tradeoff that local commit hooks do not run.

Blockers fixed / rejected findings:

  • No reviewer blocker.
  • --no-verify retained as non-blocking per reviewer rationale: hook-side effects are less acceptable for this narrow automatic Ticket metadata commit than skipping local hooks, with pathscope checks and post-validation covering the handoff.

Residual risks:

  • If sync or verify fails after the root Queue commit is created, the root/dev side remains durably queued and committed; manual follow-up may be required.
  • Clean-worktree checks are preflight checks, not a global lock against concurrent filesystem/git changes during the action.
  • Current root workspace is dirty from separate Panel/user activity (00001KTVPS6K3 queue attempt and crates/tui/src/multi_pod.rs local changes), so merge target safety must be rechecked before any merge.

Dirty state:

  • Implementation worktree was checked clean after commit.
  • Orchestrator worktree has only Ticket dossier changes before this record is committed.
  • Root/merge-target workspace is dirty and must not be used for merge until understood/cleaned or explicitly authorized.

Decision needs:

  • Explicit merge-completion authority is required before merging ticket/panel-queue-orchestrator-sync into the recorded merge target, marking final review/done/close, stopping cleanup, or deleting the worktree/branch.
  • If authority is granted later, recheck branch/worktree/commit identity, independent approval, target dirty state, and rerun post-merge validation before Ticket completion.

Implementation report

Coder/reviewer Pods stopped after merge-ready dossier was recorded.

  • Stopped: yoi-coder-panel-queue-sync
  • Stopped: yoi-reviewer-panel-queue-sync
  • Implementation worktree/branch are retained for explicit merge-completion authority.

State changed

State changed to done.

State changed

Ticket を closed にしました。

完了

Panel Queue handoff implementation was merged from ticket/panel-queue-orchestrator-sync into orchestration/yoi-orchestrator, then merged into develop.

Implemented behavior:

  • Panel Queue performs the root-side Ticket ready -> queued mutation and Queue commit.
  • The dedicated orchestration worktree is synchronized with ff-only semantics before Orchestrator notification.
  • Queue success/failure paths report Ticket id, Queue commit, sync result, and notification outcome.
  • Dirty/divergent/state-mismatch/worktree-identity failure cases are blocked with explicit diagnostics.

Validation after merge:

  • cargo fmt
  • cargo test -p client ticket_role
  • cargo test -p tui ticket_queue_notification_message_carries_routing_contract
  • target/debug/yoi ticket doctor
  • cargo check --workspace
  • nix build .#yoi
  • cargo test -p tui ticket_queue_notification_message_carries_routing_contract

Cleanup:

  • Removed implementation worktree /home/hare/Projects/yoi/.worktree/panel-queue-orchestrator-sync.
  • Deleted merged branch ticket/panel-queue-orchestrator-sync.