yoi/.yoi/tickets/00001KV04NJ8D/artifacts/review-approve-rewind-live-refresh.md

Review: approve

Reviewed implementation commits 949ceb5a and 3a7edbde against Ticket 00001KV04NJ8D intent and acceptance criteria.

Evidence:

• Event::RewindApplied no longer gates transcript restoration on App::greeting; it clears/replays the Pod-provided post-rewind entries through a shared restore path and emits an explicit warning if greeting metadata is unavailable, avoiding silent stale-view success.
• Rewind picker submit now enters an applying state, suppresses repeated Enter/navigation, shows an applying header, blocks Esc from hiding an in-flight destructive request, and closes on successful RewindApplied.
• Rewind failure (Event::Error while applying) clears the pending state, leaves the existing transcript intact, and surfaces an actionbar-visible failure plus normal error block.
• A short rewind refresh fence drops display-mutating stale live events after successful restore until authoritative Status/Snapshot; no Pod protocol or persistence semantics changed.
• Temporary investigation logging was not present in the final diff.
• Focused tests cover successful restore/old-tail removal, missing-greeting restore, duplicate-submit suppression with failure preservation, and stale live update suppression; existing rewind picker tests still pass.

Validation performed:

• git diff --check 20daae0c..HEAD: PASS.
• cargo test -p tui rewind_refresh_tests: PASS (4 tests).
• cargo test -p tui single_pod::tests::rewind_picker: PASS (2 tests).
• cargo fmt --check: PASS.
• cargo check -p protocol -p pod -p tui: PASS.
• cargo test -p tui: FAILED only in the already-reported unrelated tests: multi_pod::tests::orchestrator_launch_context_uses_orchestration_root_for_runtime_workspace and spawn::tests::{profile_choices_include_builtin_and_project_default_marker, profile_choices_use_project_registry_default}; rewind-focused tests passed in that run.

Residual note:

• The stale-update fence intentionally relies on the Pod's follow-up Status/Snapshot to clear; this matches the current RewindApplied/Status flow and is acceptable for this Ticket.

Decision: approve.