Hare/yoi
1
1
Fork 0
Code Actions Packages Releases Activity
dc8d8a0df5
yoi/.yoi/tickets/00001KW55B33H/thread.md

13 KiB
Raw Blame History

作成

LocalTicketBackend によって作成されました。

Intake summary

Marked ready by yoi ticket state.

State changed

Marked ready by yoi ticket state.

State changed

Ticket を workspace-panel が queued にしました。

Decision

Routing decision: blocked_by_dependency_or_missing_authority

Reason:

  • Dashboard Queue 後に Ticket / relations / orchestration plan / workspace state を確認した。
  • 本 Ticket は 00001KW55B33B (embedded worker-runtimeをworker crate実行に接続する) に depends_on relation を持つ。
  • 00001KW55B33B は queued で、さらに 00001KW55B32Y execution backend boundary が inprogress のため blocked。
  • Workspace Companion を実 LLM 実行 Worker として起動するには、embedded Runtime が既存 worker crate execution に接続済みである必要があるため、依存 chain 完了前に開始しない。

Evidence checked:

  • Ticket body: Companion bootstrap、Worker Console behavior、API cleanup、Validation/evidence、Non-goals。
  • Relations: outgoing depends_on -> 00001KW55B33B and related Web Console/Worker Console Tickets。
  • Orchestration plan: blocker record orch-plan-20260627-190816-1 を追加。
  • Workspace state: 00001KW55B32Y accepted/inprogress; 00001KW55B33B queued/blocked。

Next action:

  • 本 Ticket は queued のまま待機。
  • 00001KW55B33B が done になった後に再 routing する。

Decision

Routing decision:

Queue continuation was explicitly requested. The upstream dependency 00001KW55B33B is now closed after review, merge, validation, and cleanup. This Ticket is therefore unblocked and accepted for implementation.

Plan:

  • Create child implementation worktree:
    • /home/hare/Projects/yoi/.worktree/00001KW55B33H-workspace-companion-llm-worker
  • Branch:
    • work/00001KW55B33H-workspace-companion-llm-worker
  • Route implementation to a sibling Coder Worker with focused write scope.
  • Route read-only review to a sibling Reviewer Worker after implementation.
  • Orchestrator retains merge, final validation, Ticket completion, child worktree/branch cleanup, and final reporting.

Review/implementation focus:

  • Workspace Backend bootstraps workspace_companion as an executable Worker with real worker crate execution adapter.
  • Worker list / Worker Console use the normal runtime_id + worker_id authority and Backend Worker input API.
  • Console Send reaches real Worker execution path and uses protocol::Event / transcript projection, not Companion-specific fake/providerless messages.
  • provider/model/secret/profile/authority absence returns typed diagnostic and does not present the Worker as input-capable.
  • /api/companion/messages, if retained, must not return fake response and should be a thin normal Worker input path wrapper or non-authoritative compatibility path.
  • Browser-facing API must not leak raw handles, sockets, session paths, credentials, secret refs, raw manifest paths, or broad authority internals.

Operational note:

  • User instructed not to use StopPod for now after repeated stop/hang symptoms. Cleanup will skip role-Pod shutdown and remove only child worktree/branch unless this is explicitly reauthorized.

State changed

Queue continuation requested by user. Dependency 00001KW55B33B is closed with merge and validation complete, so this Ticket has no remaining blockers. Accepting implementation before child worktree / role Pod side effects.

Implementation report

Implementation kickoff:

  • Worktree created: /home/hare/Projects/yoi/.worktree/00001KW55B33H-workspace-companion-llm-worker
  • Branch: work/00001KW55B33H-workspace-companion-llm-worker
  • Coder Worker spawned: yoi-coder-00001KW55B33H-companion-llm

Scope notes:

  • Coder write scope is limited to crates/workspace-server/**, crates/worker/**, crates/worker-runtime/**, web/workspace/**, resources/profiles/**, resources/prompts/**, root Cargo.toml, Cargo.lock, and package.nix if dependency/package changes are needed.
  • Coder is instructed not to modify Ticket records and not to operate in root/orchestration worktrees.

Implementation focus:

  • bootstrap workspace_companion as an executable Worker using embedded Runtime + worker/runtime-adapter
  • normal Worker list / Worker Console attach path via runtime_id + worker_id
  • Send through Backend Worker input API to real Worker run lifecycle
  • no fake/providerless Companion response
  • provider/profile/model/secret/authority absence as typed diagnostic and not input-capable
  • /api/companion/messages, if retained, must not be a separate fake response path
  • preserve Browser-facing non-leak of raw handles, paths, credentials, secret refs, and raw manifest paths

Operational note:

  • User instructed not to use StopPod for now. Later cleanup will skip role-Pod shutdown and remove only child implementation worktree/branch unless explicitly reauthorized.

Implementation report

Implementation routing diagnostic:

Initial Coder Worker yoi-coder-00001KW55B33H-companion-llm failed before producing implementation output with provider error context_length_exceeded. This appears to be a prompt/context-size failure rather than an implementation result.

Operational response:

  • Per current user instruction, StopPod will not be used.
  • A replacement Coder Worker will be spawned with a shorter bootstrap instruction and the same implementation worktree, if scope delegation is accepted.
  • The replacement Coder should read the Ticket and current code directly from the worktree rather than receiving the full requirement text in the initial prompt.

Implementation report

Implementation/verification report:

Replacement Coder completed a verification pass in the child worktree. No code changes were made and no implementation commit was created beyond the branch baseline.

Reported branch/head:

  • 0c5a769aa90744cf12299c6d301ebfb3186d763f ticket: accept workspace companion llm worker

Reported outcome:

  • Existing code after upstream 00001KW55B33B appears to satisfy this Ticket's main implementation goal.
  • Workspace Companion is visible as an embedded Runtime normal Worker.
  • The worker runtime-adapter path is used; providerless/fake responses were not found.
  • Input unavailable state is represented through Worker input-capable/diagnostic projection.
  • Workspace web Worker Console uses runtime_id + worker_id routing.

Reported validation:

  • cargo fmt --check: success
  • cd web/workspace && deno task test: success
  • cd web/workspace && deno task check: success
  • cd web/workspace && deno task build: success
  • cargo test -p yoi-workspace-server: success
  • cargo check -p yoi: success
  • git diff --check: success
  • nix build .#yoi: success

Orchestrator note:

  • Because no code commit was produced for this Ticket, a reviewer will be asked to explicitly verify whether upstream merged implementation fully satisfies 00001KW55B33H or whether additional changes are required.

Implementation report

Review kickoff:

Reviewer Worker spawned to verify the no-code implementation/verification outcome for 00001KW55B33H.

  • Reviewer Worker: yoi-reviewer-00001KW55B33H-companion
  • Review mode: read-only review of current child worktree code state after upstream 00001KW55B33B merge
  • Special focus: confirm whether no additional code changes are required for this Ticket, or identify concrete blockers

Review focus:

  • workspace_companion bootstraps as an executable normal Worker via embedded Runtime + worker/runtime-adapter
  • Worker list / Worker Console attach path uses runtime_id + worker_id
  • Send uses Backend Worker input API -> embedded Runtime execution backend -> real Worker run lifecycle
  • protocol events / transcript use existing Console rendering path
  • missing provider/config/profile/secret/authority is typed diagnostic and not input-capable
  • /api/companion/messages does not return fake/providerless response
  • Browser-facing API does not leak raw handles, socket paths, session paths, credentials, secret refs, raw manifest paths, or broad authority internals
  • public can_stream_events / can_read_bounded_transcript flags are not revived

Review: request changes

request_changes

静的レビューの結果、upstream の worker-runtime adapter 実装は存在するが、Ticket 00001KW55B33H 自体の受け入れ条件はまだ満たされていない。

Blockers

  1. /api/companion/messages がまだ hard-coded な非実行 path のまま

    • server.rs:533-537 は /api/companion/messages を直接 api.companion.send_message(request) に route している。
    • companion.rs:161-182 は non-empty input を常に companion_llm_not_connected で reject する。
    • これは Backend Worker input API の thin wrapper ではなく、real Worker run lifecycle に到達しないため、Ticket の /api/companion/messages 要件を満たさない。

  2. Companion status / transport が古い “not connected” limitation をまだ宣言している

    • companion.rs:337-342 が completion: "not_connected" を返し、実 Worker/LLM execution 接続まで browser input は disabled と説明している。
    • Ticket の目的は Workspace Companion を real LLM execution に接続して Web Console から使えるようにすることなので矛盾している。

  3. Companion bootstrap が適切な Companion profile / config bundle を解決していない

    • companion.rs:257-267 は profile: Some(ProfileSelector::RuntimeDefault) / config_bundle: None で spawn している。
    • hosts.rs:2188-2191 では RuntimeDefault が runtime_default と投影されるだけで、Companion profile として表示されない。
    • Ticket は Companion Profile / config bundle を解決し、workspace_companion / 適切な companion Profile として表示することを求めている。

  4. focused tests が古い rejected/no-output behavior をまだ assert している

    • companion.rs:384-399 は send_message("hello") が Rejected、companion_llm_not_connected、runtime transcript empty であることを assert している。
    • server.rs:1166-1185 は /api/companion/messages が rejected で transcript empty であることを assert している。
    • Ticket は bootstrap、input dispatch、assistant output、observation event、transcript projection が Worker execution path を通ることを proving する tests を求めている。

  5. raw path leak 懸念

    • server.rs:227-235 の WorkspaceResponse に local_root: PathBuf が含まれる。
    • server.rs:335-339 が /api/workspace に api.config.workspace_root を serialize している。
    • “no raw handle/path/credential leaks” を Browser-facing workspace API 全体に適用するなら違反の可能性がある。Worker projection 自体はより注意深く redacted されているが、この public path field は残っているため要確認・必要なら修正が必要。

確認済み / non-blocking observations

  • upstream embedded runtime adapter は存在する。
    • WorkspaceApi::new が WorkerRuntimeExecutionBackend::from_workspace(...) を作り、EmbeddedWorkerRuntime::new_memory_with_execution_backend(...) に渡している。
  • Worker list / Console routing は runtime_id + worker_id を使っている。
    • Console Send は /api/runtimes/{runtime_id}/workers/{worker_id}/input。
    • Observation WS は /api/runtimes/{runtime_id}/workers/{worker_id}/events/ws。
  • public can_stream_events / can_read_bounded_transcript fields は見当たらない。
  • /api/companion/messages は fake/canned assistant response は返していないが、same execution path / normal Worker input path 要件も満たしていない。

Validation review

  • .yoi/tickets/00001KW55B33H/item.md と thread.md を読んだ。
  • crates/workspace-server/src/{companion.rs,server.rs,hosts.rs}、crates/worker/src/runtime_adapter.rs、Web Console Svelte/TS paths を静的レビューした。
  • test/build は実行していない。
  • 現状の cargo test -p yoi-workspace-server は古い rejected Companion behavior を assert して通っている可能性があり、この Ticket の acceptance evidence にはならない。